Scoreboard:

Scoreboard

a
Story
90%
Characters
95%
Art
95%
Animation
90%
Sound
88%
Overall
92%
ProsCons
Nice comedy, likable main character, good surprises, steady progressionSome love or hate characters, not all mysteries resolved

Review:

There are just series that turn out better than people would have expected and just defy expectations. I really have to make “Mikakunin de Shinkoukei” or “Engaged to the Unidentified” as one of them. The first episode pretty much had this series as not getting much credit out of the gate. It’s really hard not to give myself credit for thinking this was going to be good and it ending up being good. I won’t because I didn’t actually end up covering it. I will say though that this is definitely a contender in my mind as the best series from the winter season. This series has good laughs, consistent character development and wasn’t afraid to continually make key revelations. Almost every episode felt like something important had happened and that helps keep the interest going.

Mikakunin_00_2Mikakunin_00_3Mikakunin_00_4Mikakunin_00_5

Mikakunin de Shinkoukei just did things right when it comes to the main character and making proper use of the supporting cast. Romantic comedies are going to be tricky things to pull off right since comedy really is such a subjective thing. But I feel this series did the right thing in keeping the focus as much on Kobeni as possible. Because this was the show where the girl was without a doubt the main character here. Everyone else acted in support and while doing a good job of that it did allow Kobeni to shine as a character.

Kobeni was a really well done character all things considered. They managed to strike a good balance with her that I liked quite a bit. She wasn’t the perfect character by a long shot. Pretty weak in sports, has a serious inferiority complex when it comes to her mother and sister, is uncomfortable standing out, etc. But all her flaws did have some basis to them and did make her a more interesting person. Her sister is almost inhuman in how talented she is in athletics, academics, and pure charisma. It’s only natural to feel inferior to someone like that. Her health issues weren’t just thrown in to make her a sympathetic character, but actually had good reasoning behind it.

In the end Kobeni is just a purely likable character. A considerate person who does take things hard when she feels responsible. Tends to play the straight man because she is surrounded by a lot of unusual people, but can get carried away herself. Sometimes plays the tsundere when it comes to her romantic feelings, but isn’t hard to read and is someone you want to see things go well for. But even saying that Kobeni wasn’t really any specific stereotype. Which was one of the things I did like about her, Kobeni was just herself.

Mikakunin_00_6Mikakunin_00_7Mikakunin_00_8Mikakunin_00_9

While I could go on forever about Kobeni, there was a whole cast for this show too XD. Obviously the character who got the most early concern is the main (if actually only) male character in Hakuya. First impressions probably weren’t great for him because he is a more quiet type that doesn’t easily get across his feelings. Honestly early on you could almost consider him the male version of the Ayanami Rei archetype. Which is odd because in a female character it’s great but in a male character not so much. Though really that’s not what he is. Really Hakuya is a good character and develops nicely through the series. He is one of the more quiet types that thinks about things and usually says things that have impact.

Hakuya does open up through the series and while not a chatty character even at the end, he gets his feelings across clearly. It’s more about reading the tone, expressions with him. He’s a really considerate person who has some similarities to Kobeni. Both characters can really beat themselves up over things they feel was their fault and both do try to consider the other person’s situation. While Hakuya arrives as this fiance he really tries not pressuring Kobeni or overwhelming her with information. Because one other thing I did forget to mention was that Kobeni did lose some memories of her childhood so this really is a sudden change in her life having Hakuya and Mashiro show up. Simply put, Hakuya is a good person and is clear about expressing his feelings about Kobeni if nothing else.

The other two main girls in the Kobeni household are her sister Benio and Hakuya’s sister Mashiro. Both are definitely two of the main drives for the comedy in the series. Mashiro is a cute young girl who tries to act mature, but often has no problem doing childish things when they catch her attention. Someone who cares quite a bit about her family and is an important intermediary between Kobeni and Hakuya since she is more expressive than her brother. She really doesn’t play the sister-in-law card long before she just feels like part of the family without trying. Nothing is more fun than when Mashiro allows herself to not need to act so mature and be as childish as she wants.

Mikakunin_00_10Mikakunin_00_11Mikakunin_00_12Mikakunin_00_13

Benio is….well Benio. If there was a bizarre entity in this series it would be her. Honestly, she’s probably the most flawed person in the series. While Kobeni has all her problems, Benio has a handful of huge ones. She can play the elite athlete, the student counsel president, the intelligent academic, but wow her downsides are equally impressive. She’s imouto obsessed maniac. It doesn’t even need to be her actual little sister in Kobeni, Mashiro is also a fair target. Almost at yandere levels with how obsessed she is. All the housework and cooking that Kobeni is amazing at is something that’s impossible for Benio to handle. She really has no sense of limits and you just have ot watch out when she gets going. I’ll say Benio is often a good source of comedy, but she can also cross the line. The balance in the series is not giving her too much screen time that you get annoyed with her.

When in doubt though, Benio’s friend Nadeshko is key for shutting her down. The one person in the series who sees both sides of Benio and will just outright knock her around if it means getting her back on track. The other side characters are pretty good. Kobeni’s friend Mayura is important as a confidant for Kobeni who is dealing with her romantic troubles, Konoha is a Benio fangirl who actually has more plot relevance as the series goes on and Niko is Konoha’s friend and an obsessed reporter that actually can go beyond Benio level of insanity at times. As a whole the cast for this series was a good one. Everyone did well in their roles and supported the heroine of this story nicely.

Mikakunin_00_14Mikakunin_00_15Mikakunin_00_16Mikakunin_00_17

Moving on from the characters, the story itself was good. It never left it’s main objective of following Kobeni as she finds out she has a finance and deals with this major change in her life. The story just helps make that an interesting journey. What was really enjoyable about this show was how every step along the story had something interesting happening. It didn’t feel cheap, but a natural extension of what was going on. We learn more about Kobeni, we learn more about Hakuya and Mashiro, we see how various discoveries affect Kobeni, things like that. The series does pull off some interesting surprises, but they do them well. Even the most strange of developments does tie into the overall plot. Just when I thought I had the full picture there was just a little bit more to learn.

Even by the end there are still some things that could have been delved into, but nothing I felt needed to in order to have a satisfying conclusion. And really one of the strong suits for this series is the consistent feel of the story. It always feels like we were moving forward right to the end. And honestly the final episode for this series was practically perfect in my mind. It continued the pattern of moving the story forward and just did it in a way that made me almost want to applaud it for a job well done. It’s so easy for series to stumble at the finish. The kind of ending where they can continue on (and I’m sure in the source material it does) it ends on a pont where I can just walk away with a smile. All this from a series adopted from a 4-koma manga. It never felt like one, the story just moving forward in a way that felt natural.

Mikakunin_00_18Mikakunin_00_19Mikakunin_00_20Mikakunin_00_21

The music was pretty good for this series. It probably has one of the most fun combinations of OP/ED for series currently airing. Both have a nice feel to the music and the visuals especially for the OP are active and entertaining. One of the few times I watched the OP/ED for a series for just about every episode. Even if you don’t watch the series it’s probably worth checking out the OP/ED. The OP especially does a good job introducing the characters, but having some interesting art going along with it. Really I give props to the voice actresses for Kobeni, Benio, and Mashiro who do the singing here. Music as a whole was pretty good, it never overly stood out to me, but simply supported the visuals.

I’ll say the voice work was also well done in this series. Of the main characters only Hakuya’s voice actor has a lot of experience. Kobeni, Mashiro, and Benio all had actresses who haven’t got large resumes or having done major characters up till this point. And really I think they all did an exceptional job there. I’m looking forward to more series for all of them since they really sold those characters to me.

Visually I had no complaints for this one. This isn’t the kind of show that often needs any flashy animation, but it did step up when needed. I’d say it was pretty high quality and certainly above average. For a series where you’ll be watching the characters more than anything that’s a good thing.

Mikakunin_00_22Mikakunin_00_23Mikakunin_00_24Mikakunin_00_25

In the end this is a series I’d fully recommend to people. Obviously if you aren’t interested in a romantic comedy then this wouldn’t be a fit, but I do think it’s worth checking out in general. Considering some reactions on the first episode I’d support the idea of going with the 3 episode rule. Within that many episodes it will show you just what kind of series you can expect. This was a very consistent series and I’d say consistently good. I had plenty of laughs and really did enjoy the development of Kobeni’s character and her relationship with Hakuya. This series focused on its premise and by the end of the series a lot of ground had been covered and without feeling rushed.

This season was certainly a weaker one in general. Only a few series I’d consider really good with a few that were simply average. Still, this was definitely one of the good ones. It told a great story and left me in a position where I’d love to see more. Easy call for me to give this an A grade.
Score: A

Monthly Sponsor



Advertise on Anime Evo!

Help us pay the bills and work with us to promote your awesome product, service, website, comic or anything else you want to show off. We here at Anime Evo work with our advertising partners to promote products that are actually relevant to our audience, and give you the best bang for your buck!

Current Series

About

An older member at 25, yet a new addition to Anime Evo. Recently graduating University and in the difficult point between school and a true career. Anime being a salvation and blogging a good way to put all those hours of writing essays to some use. Enjoys talking about series, yet not taking on so many that the quality dips. A Canadian who enjoys his anime and hearing what others think about the series he enjoys watching.

Discussion Rules

Comments on Anime Evo are not only welcome, but the thing that we writers look forward to the most. Please, however, bear in mind that there are certain things that you just can't do as it ruins the fun for everyone:

  • No Spoilers of Any kind please. No hints, no discussion of future stuff from the source manga/light novel. Keep the discussion to the current episode's events, and that's it.
  • No personal attacks. Debates/Disagreements are okay, but keep things civil and be nice.
  • No advertising/Links to promote your personal website/article/products. We have a way to advertise on the site if you're interested.
  • setsuken

    Its sad how bad of a first impression this show made, not on just myself, but on many others.

    The focus on just Kobeni was a bit jarring at first, as its really hard to tell what this series is about from the onset.

    That said, I totally agree with everything you mention in this review. Should you give this series a chance, it really is a heart warming, and often times hilarious series. Most of the hilarity I got from the series was because of Benio acting like a complete nut.

    Benio is over the top, but the series loses its character without her. Kobeni, as you said, is the very likable girl, and I’m sure a lot of people in Japan are probably going crazy for that kind of character. Its as you said, she’s nice and likeable, but she’s not perfect, which really gives her that air of realism that few female characters have. Yet, I’m male and I definitely felt like not only Kobeni, but the entire series was kind of made for me.

    I do not think that a woman like Benio exists in the real world (though if she did, It would be friggin hilarious and awesome), and I do think that despite her flaws, even Kobeni is a bit idealized.

    I thought, for a good chunk of time that Hakuya was the weakest link of the series, and honestly after the first few episodes, even he becomes pretty endearing.

    The fact that both my comment, and a good chunk of your review talks about the characters well… that’s a testament to just how well done the characters are, and how much this is a character driven show.

    All in all, this was a great show, but I’m not sure if I would recommend this to everyone. Very hardcore Slice of Life/Comedy fans will like this show, and while I’d still rate it as an A Grade show myself, I guess its sad to think that this is a show that most of the anime fandom on the internet largely passed on.

    Ah well, the good thing about the anime industry is that rare and unique niche shows like this exist, right? =D

    • FlareKnight

      Of course I did enjoy the first episode as a whole, I could see where the concerns were coming from out of the gate. It definitely didn’t take long for the series to find its legs and just carry itself straight ahead without really stumbling past that point. Always seems to be a couple shows that just get passed by despite the fact that they are really enjoyable.

      The cast really is what carried it. There was some good developments along the way, but they always kept it tied to the characters themselves. Definitely a character driven series and it had good characters taking the lead.

      I think Kobeni is an interesting character because of the balance between making her really likable and trying to keep some weak points. After all a perfect character can get pretty boring so it was key to figure that out. But even Kobeni’s weaknesses never made her a bad person. It wasn’t like her flaw was being a violent tsundere XD. Was nice though that so much did have reasoning behind it and tied into the story well.

      Agreed that without Benio the series would lose something. I think Benio and Mashiro were critical for carrying the comedy and taking some attention of the main pair. Made it so it wasn’t too much of one thing. I’d be scared to meet someone like Benio, but she’s entertaining in small doses. You just want to make sure she doesn’t cross the line into criminal.

      Hakuay’s development went pretty nicely. Does open up more so it’s easier to like him from a viewers point of view. He does open up at time which avoids being a cold character that you can’t get behind. Though the they also avoided what might have been a big error in forcing Hakuya into the lead role which he just wouldn’t have done as well in.

      Definitely a show that can have pretty wide recommendation. A good combination of slice and life, comedy, and some romance tossed in.

      It’s really shows like these that keep me watching. You’ll always have the big hits that are obviously enjoyable and likeable. But then you’ll have these ones that don’t get the same acclaim but are plenty enjoyable as well.

  • Algirdas Lekavicius

    I’m glad I ended up sticking with with this anime for the season, it wasn’t perfect, but it wasn’t bad. The beginning really threw me off like everyone else, but as you’ve mentioned they got on track pretty quick. Mashiro made this series for me, I watched it exclusively for her because she is pretty funny and just sooooo damn cute. I think the animation really did it for me also, the character expressions and animesque emotional effects just made watching it a breeze.

    The show did stretch a bit long for me near the end, I thought the White Day stuff was a little drawn out and kind of dry. I also felt like throughout the show they made problems for the protagonists, but then never really explored them. The situation with Konoha wanting to marry Hakuya could have been a really nasty conundrum, but never picked up the steam to make it a full blown dilemma. Likewise Konoha leaking info to her reporter friend or the whole UMA dilemma at the end could have been really interesting if they had gone more in depth. The whole supernatural twist at the halfway point actually made the series a lot more interesting throughout. As for Kobeni, for me she wasn’t as likeable as she was just too innocent/weak, always setting up the white knight situation for everyone else which was predictable and boring. I was surprised that we didn’t get a neat wrap up near the end, that they didn’t kiss or move forward their relationship that much. Maybe they’re keeping it open for a sequel or something.

    Overall, no emotional roller-coasters here, just a fun thing to watch with barely enough plot to keep you wondering what next episode will add, but then again not everything needs to be over the top and I ended up enjoying the show a lot. Also, yes the OP/ED music and animation were awesome, I always looked forward to hearing the songs every episode! Now I gotta go finish watching Noragami so I can see what you guys thought of it!

    P.S. Also glad to see that you all were watching the same stuff on the side as me, even if you didn’t do episode by episode reviews 🙂

    • FlareKnight

      Long as we were all on the same journey that’s good by me XD.

      I agree Mashiro was a key character for the series. She had her own comedic element, but she was a good buffer for a lot of the characters. Her relationship with Hakuya, Kobeni, and even Benio helped make the series better. Just a cute character and pretty funny in her own right. Just listened to her character songs….all I’ll say is very fitting.

      I can certainly see what you mean. I didn’t think the White Day stuff was too bad, but that was the one point in the series where I did feel them holding things up a bit. Over the course of the series though it wasn’t too big a thing.

      I felt like they kept the focus on Kobeni’s development while slowly bringing out the truth of the whole situation. With the engagement they spent time focusing on the key element of it which was how Kobeni felt and really why this was all happening.

      It could have been interesting to delve more into the reporter angle or the UMA stuff, but at the same time it felt like everything in the series was used to further push the main storyline. The pressure from the reporting or Konoha making her move was to push Kobeni into continuing to develop while getting a better understanding of the characters.

      With Kobeni I was ok with her character because she made sense to me. Could have just made her a fragile character for little reason and went with it. But with everything she went through and how she grew up as a result, her personality made sense and that was enough for me. Really feels like we’ve just gotten a small part of a much larger character arc for Kobeni where she can continue to grow from. They could have pushed the relationship more, but I’m ok with where it stands. Where it started from “who is this person” to where it ended, that’s decent progress especially since there is source material that is presumably ongoing.

      With some of the series I’ve watched this season, I can certainly appreciate a bit of stability. This series had its surprises, but it never felt like I was riding an emotional roller coaster.

  • Pingback: Anime Evo » Top Ten Anime Series of 2014 according to Flower….()