Anime Evo RSS Feed Anime Evo Facebook Page Anime Evo Twitter

Sword_02_1

Well this episode proves that being a main character can really demand suffering at times. Kirito making a personal sacrifice in order to eliminate the hate towards the beta testers and allow everyone else to get closer as a consequence. A kind of uniting everyone by making him someone for everyone (including beta testers) to hate. Not that much of what he said was inaccurate, but clearly was done with the intent to make everyone in that room forget about hating all the beta testers.

Only a few months in, but we are starting to see how people are adapting to this situation. Asuna made it clear that plenty are just hiding in the first town inns rather than racing out into the wilds to try and level themselves up. Not surprising since the moment you are told that you’ll die if you lose then a sense of self-preservation kicks in and it’s fight or flight. Of course in a sense it’s not like anything has changed from real life. If they got hit by a car they’d die just the same. Though suppose it’s closer to getting drafted for a war and suddenly realizing just how mortal you really are. While I can understand their feelings about wanting to stay safe, I can also understand where Asuna is coming from. The last thing some would want to do is just rot away. By staying put the person that she is would already be dead. Can see the differences in people who would rather die as themselves than simply survive and lose themselves.

Still on the note of how people react it’s kind of sad how much hate the beta testers were getting. I mean let’s forget about hating on the guy who has trapped them in a world where they will die if they lose and instead hate on the people who have experience. A lot of what Kibaou said was simply guesswork. I’m sure some testers like Kirito were quick to leave that town and move on, but that could be the same for those who had experience in MMOs. Not like anyone looks special because they played in the beta so no way to actually tell. Just assuming because no one said “hey I played in the beta, let’s do some tutorial stuff” that they were all gone. Plenty could be hiding in inns as well just as afraid of dying. I get that people in a stressful situation want someone to blame and blaming someone you can see is easier than a figure that you can’t get to. Still it’s just annoying that Kirito has to take on all this just because that idiot couldn’t keep his mouth shut and had to return to his beta tester hate.

So far I like Asuna and think she’ll be an interesting character to keep an eye on in the series. Can see some similarities to Kirito if only because she’s not much of a group person either. Hadn’t even gotten into a party in those two months and just survived on her own. Think she wasn’t in the beta and simply left the town because she hated seeing those who were too afraid to do anything. The fact she was surprised by how Kirito knew her name seems to reflect that inexperience and yet she is really skilled. Do wonder about the cloak she was wearing most of the time. Could look at it in a few ways after all. Maybe just trying to project that barrier to keep people away. Could also be because she’s a girl and after everyone’s real appearance was revealed could see what girls there are in the game getting approached to join parties and guilds often. Doesn’t seem like she’ll be going in the same direction as Kirito right away though obviously they’ll end up going through this crazy game together soon enough.

I thought the battle against the boss was pretty well done. Really is something having those game elements mixing in with obviously the very real threat of dying. That familiarity with health bars and parties, but consequences far higher than any actual game. Makes you wonder if some people just ended up dying because they didn’t have their guards up. Easy to forget that it isn’t just a game anymore when you see all those familiar things, especially if their world is similar to now where for a lot of games there isn’t a major consequence for dying. I don’t know, it’s just something that has stood out for me. You see a character’s health bar go down and now have to feel worried about their survival. It’s a very real way to judge the safety of a character.

On a side note at least it seems like for the early part of this game people aren’t going in quite as blind as I thought they were. The beta testers did leave quite a bit of data behind, though as this episode proved things were changed. I’m not surprised that someone who would do this wouldn’t change things up so beta testers wouldn’t have an easy time climbing up even a few floors. At least for this boss some information was available. The higher that everyone goes though the less information they are going to have. Suppose they could have groups going in to scout the abilities of bosses and then running for it, but that’s going to be a dangerous business. The death toll is bound to skyrocket as people run into the tougher bosses with nothing to base their tactics on. Probably only those that can adapt on the fly are going to be able to make it through those encounters.

Kirito sure knows how to look like a villain

In the end it sucks that Kirito has to take this burden onto himself. Think he shouldn’t feel too responsible for Diabel’s death. The guy put himself at risk because he wanted that item bonus. Understandable, but even he should know some bonus item from the first floor boss isn’t going to be useful right to the very end. But I suppose every bit counts and when you can’t afford to die even once that rare item might mean life or death. Regardless he charged in there and got himself killed. He was too reliant on either his own experience or what was put in that guide. Even if it meant risking the item he should have gone with the group and in that case he might have been able to survive.

Maybe in the end Kirito’s decision was partly motivated by his self-blame. If he’d been more like Diabel (not selfishly going for the item, but leading everyone) than things might not have turned out like that. At the very least he could make sure that the other beta testers avoided getting any more hate piled on them. It hurts his own chances for survival since no one (at least from his perspective) will join up with him from this point forward. He knows that going solo isn’t going to allow him to make it to the top, but he said all that anyways. On the positive that title of a ‘beater’ actually does sound pretty cool if you don’t know the meaning behind it. Not exactly sure why they bothered calling him a cheater since he simply played a ton during the beta. Anyone could have gone as far as he did if they actually put that time into it. Sad that guys like that who can only blame others (and probably will just get themselves killed anyways) have to make this terrible situation even more stressful for others. Curious to see though how Kirito is going to get through this now that he’s got that stigma attached to him. Also I have to say for a guy who was nervous about meeting Klein’s friends he played the villain quite well.

OP [Crossing Field] by LiSA: (A)

I honestly like the OP. The music was definitely the type that I liked for an OP, namely it was fast and full of energy. Definitely a good way to get into an episode for a series that is likely to have as much action as this one will. A ton of focus being given to Kirito and Asuna which makes sense as they’ve proven to be the main characters for this series. Seems like both of them have things weighing them down though it seems for Asuna the story of her real life before this game should be interesting. Even without the second episode could somewhat understand why these two are going to form a bond. Seem like a couple of people who are pretty lonely. Of course the OP wasn’t just about them with flashes of other girls (either party members and/or potential love interests) and of course some flashes of guys who I assume will be important figures in this story. At least the OP seems to confirm that Klein is going to be just fine and fairly important.

ED [Yume Sekai] by Haruka Tomatsu: (B)

The ED was pretty simple really. Just panning down a screen with Kirito kind of floating in the air above and Asuna inverted below. Not that the series needs to point out that these two are the main characters, but it was a nice touch. The song itself was pretty nice and kind of calming. Nothing special visually, but after listening to the song a few times have to say I like the ED for this show.

In the end have to say the second episode went well. Got to jump into a boss battle and seeing how people have reacted to this whole situation. Things are only going to get tougher from this point onwards. Just going to look forward to seeing where the story goes and how Kirito and Asuna manage to stay alive in this crazy situation.
Score: A



About :

An older member at 25, yet a new addition to Anime Evo. Recently graduating University and in the difficult point between school and a true career. Anime being a salvation and blogging a good way to put all those hours of writing essays to some use. Enjoys talking about series, yet not taking on so many that the quality dips. A Canadian who enjoys his anime and hearing what others think about the series he enjoys watching.


  • Ingu

    “If he’d been more like Diabel (not selfishly going for the item, but leading everyone)”

    ow come on, Diabel was the last hitting bitch, using everyone there, not some great leader, they just fucked up explaining it, gah they fucked up whole ep

    read novel, or if you don’t have time for that at least read what mdz wrote https://mdzanime.wordpress.com/2012/07/14/sword-art-online-aria-its-shitty-adaptation/

    • setsuken

      After having read MDZ’s little article, I will say that what he says makes sense, and I do indeed agree that according to the novel, this isn’t exactly the best adaption ever, but its only been two episodes. In adaptions, some things get shifted around, and change, but they might bring in the essence of what the story was about.

      Now, again, I think the way the anime set Diebel up, he seemed to be a beta tester that was trying to be the leader and lead everyone to safety, and using his knowledge from the beta testing and what not to keep everyone going. He ALSO needed to be the strongest, since no one really obeys a weak leader and hence I think that’s why he rushed for that rare item. At least… according to the anime.

      I really don’t recommend reading above link, because it does have some minor spoilers. Again, there’s a lot of worth of evaluating the Anime based on its own merits.

      Yes, as an adaption, this show would be a HUGE disappointment, but as an original anime episode, I quite enjoyed it!

    • FlareKnight

      Definitely think it’s good to have the link giving people a chance to take note of the differences and what was left out. Have certainly seen enough complaining to make me glad I wrote this before I looked around to see other views on the episode.

      I wasn’t exactly cutting Diabel slack here. I very well doubt his entire motivation was scoring the rare item. They needed to bring this boss down in order to proceed. Everything he said made sense and really without him who knows how many more months it would have taken for a group to come together to bring that guy down. Yeah he was selfish in wanting the last item, though at the same time can’t afford to be someone that people aren’t going to follow. Forget the last item but being the guy to finish it off would create a positive amount of support. Nothing really wrong with someone wanting better items in order to stay alive longer either. In the end the guy died so I’m not going to jump on him. His last words weren’t about his own death but wanting that group to survive so I’ll judge him a good guy.

      In the end though I’m probably not going to check out the link. I’m going to keep this as pure of an anime-only view on the series as humanly possible. If there’s one thing I’ve learned from reading novels before watching the anime it’s a bad idea since it taints the whole thing. End up focusing more on what’s left out than the positives of the anime itself. Will probably check it out after this is all over, but only at that point.

  • setsuken

    This episode was kind of a mixed bag for me. Yes, it was thrilling, interesting and exciting, filled with drama and some interesting bits, yet some larger questions about how Sword Art Online works are what really kept killing the immersion for me.

    For one, How are people still alive after a month? Does time work differently inside the SAO or does the VR Machine keep sustaining them? This is something quite important that hasn’t been touched on, especially given the rather emphasizing danger on not disconnecting the game?

    Secondly, how do these items get distributed? The journal/guide book was given to everyone, but how and where?

    The link our good friend Ingu shared kind of explains some of guide/information broker stuff, but it really is not covered in the anime.

    What I did love, in this episode, was the whole boss fight scene! That was quite amazing, all the way up to Kirito getting that badass black coat and pulling a Lelouch, becoming the villain.

    Now… Again, in the novel his motivations are explained a bit more clearly, and while I “think” Kirito gave everyone a common foe to hate, his motivations could be slightly more complex or different. I am interested to see if they touch on the whole “beater” concept, it was a pretty clever and interesting term that came out of the whole thing.

    Also, Asuna was a pretty interesting character. Can’t wait to see her follow Kirito and stuff.

    Overall, while there are some things that are clearly bothering me, given how I am (someone who needs stuff explained to a certain degree to suspend my sense of disbelief), I still found this episode to be quite entertaining and exciting.

    Can’t wait to see what comes next!

    • FlareKnight

      I’m not too worried about the people staying alive part myself. True that it’d be good to know exactly how people are being kept alive and hopefully the series touches on that sooner rather than later. Otherwise I was assuming that their rooms have been pretty much converted into places that can care for coma patients. You bring in some IVs and monitoring technology and just do the work necessary to keep someone alive. Expect everyone will look terrible and have muscles degenerated from doing nothing for long periods, but not like keeping people alive is impossible to do even now. If time was moving differently then we’d have to assume the guy was lying about people getting their helmets removed since no one would do that so quickly.

      In terms of the guide book have a few thoughts. Since Kirito said there were so many different skills figured that the beta tester behind it worked up to a book binding skill, made the guide and then sold copies to an item shop that could then be used to distribute the guide to new players. Not to mention entirely possible that people bought multiple copies and traded it to friends to help continue the spread. In a future MMO all of it should be possible. While I do think it’d be nice to add information and explain more it didn’t feel like information that was going to ruin the episode by not diving into. A guide book that will only be semi-useful due to changes from the beta isn’t a big deal in the end anyways.

      Think there are only so many ways to interpret Kirito’s actions. They show everyone kind of starting to turn on each other, focus on Diabel’s last words, etc. About the only reason I can think of is uniting everyone in hating him, stopping the suspicion of each other (so they can work together going forward), and taking the pressure of all the beta testers. There could be more to it, but right now I think that’s pretty good. Someone who’s that uncomfortable getting involved with people suddenly acting in a way to make everyone hate him can only have a few explanations behind it.

      Can definitely see how some would need some explanations for things to fit better. Normally I’m right there, though in this case I’m more than willing to wait and just take the series as it comes. Nothing really managed to break my acceptance of this game’s universe. Certainly some stuff to think about, but for now it’s full steam ahead for me.

      • http://www.facebook.com/people/Justin-Miller/703922941 Justin Miller

        I thought it was a great episode made me want to play a mmo i have read the LN and i cant find anything wrong with the episode..i wonder if i am one of those people who are just happy to see a great series animated.

        In answer to flareknights question about how are they being kept alive welll..im pretty sure the creator of the game in the beginning said that he had alerted the mass media and all the trapped players have been moved to nearby hospitals that can care for there bodies and that he had stopped the nervegears killing them while they were being moved

        • setsuken

          Aha! I missed that part about the hospitals. That would definitely make sense, as people could be hooked up to drips and what not to keep them alive.

        • FlareKnight

          That would definitely make a lot of sense. I figured if they couldn’t be moved period they’d have to set up that kind of situation in the person’s own house, but moving them all to hospitals would allow for much easier supervision. After that point it’s pretty much just treating them like they are in comas.

    • Kid Kaos

      accourding to the novel, their real bodies’ location where sent to nearby hospitals, and they where picked up and put in a coma state. this should have been explained in the first episode (when Kayaba was telling eveyone about the SAO) but for some reason it was left out (why could they skip such an important detail?!)

  • LighGaiden

    Now, i have not read the novels since i really dont have that big of a passion for manga (but i watch it equally as much as i play games) but i just thought of a GREAT! twist that could be legitimate.
    What if the creater didnt intend to kill but fooled the players to believe in the “game over, hi death!” to find if people pick success or safety in such an event and if you die in the game you come back to reality but can´t play anymore and have to wait for friends to die or win till you can talk to them and play etc.
    But when they come back to reality either way they can´t tell the players about it!
    And what if the helmets dont kill but remove a function from the brain like sight, smell, pain, intelligence, speech or something like that and the parents decide not to do that to their dear children by ripping of the helmet by force.
    Now this anime are not likely to go down that road but you never know.
    If their´s a contradiction in my theory dont hesitate to tell me but…
    Don´t be a d*ck ok?

    • FlareKnight

      Don’t worry the last thing I’d ever do is outright rip into someone XD.

      Think I had heard someone talk about this possibility. Think you covered your bases pretty well. Dying in a fight gets you out just fine, while ripping off the helmet would have a pretty serious penalty. Thus no one is being ripped out of there. The cost of forcing them out is higher than the cost of letting them die in the game so most would hold back from doing that. No one can get back in so the players would believe that people died and no one could just force their way into the game to tell differently.

      Now in terms of possible problems we’d have to assume that the creator faked the news feed he showed the players. While possible, at least what we saw is that people did die from getting the helmets removed.

      Also the message at the end of the first episode saying 2,000 died in the first month seems to contradict it. It’s not for the players to see and resembles a historical record or news article. If people are just being trapped without a kill function it seems a bit strange.

      I think there is some good stuff in the theory. But it’s kind of like speculating about the creator’s motives. We just don’t have anything to go on as to why he is doing this. If we don’t know why then we can’t really confirm that he’s not the type to kill or that he’s the type to kill. Think for now might as well take the series at face value. Can always change viewpoints when information comes forward to help that argument.