Scoreboard:

Scoreboard

a
Story
93%
Characters
95%
Art
85%
Animation
60%
Sound
94%
Overall
90%
ProsCons
Great Story & Characters, Impressive Art Direction, Great Sound workBad Animation, Feels Rushed near the end

 

Review:

For the romance-comedy fan, the name Jun Maeda has at least influenced your viewing experience. Jun Maeda is one of the lead story writers of Visual Kei, the famous visual novel company that has produced works such as Clannad, Kannon and AIR, all of which have been adapted into very successful anime series. Not content with just influencing the romance genre from the shadows, Angel Beats! is the first series that Jun Maeda has written from scratch and directed. How well does it stack up to all the previous masterpieces that he’s been a part of?

The short and simple answer is that Angel Beats! is just as good, if not better than anything else we’ve seen that Maeda-san has been involved with. At the same time, the answer really isn’t all that simple. Angel beats! is a show with great emotion and heart, that really does tug at your heartstrings, but it is not a romance show. Being something totally different, and actually covering a new topic of leading life and death, and doing it so well, with such heart and feeling, is the real accomplishment of Angel Beats!

Angel Beats! centers around Yuzuru Otonashi, a young man who wakes up in a strange world only to find that everyone there has actually died. He asked by Yurippe, a  girl who leads the “Afterlife Battlefront” to join in the rebellion against God, as everyone here doesn’t accept death and fights against it. In opposition to the Battlefront, is a young girl, who they term as the “Angel”. Otonashi reluctantly joins the Battlefront, all the while, trying to get his memories and make sense of what is happening. That’s the general starting anyway. Angel beats! introduces a handful of plot twists in the first few episodes alone, and there are a good bunch of surprises all the way till the end.

There’s a belief, that too many plot twists make a story convoluted. This series begs to differ, with an amazing plot filled with twists and turns. The story in Angel beats! is one of Jun Maeda’s best works by far, and it is in uncharted territory as far as anime series go. Instead of focusing on events during one’s life, the core theme of Angel Beats! is all about looking at life in retrospect. The whole concept of the afterlife, and what one may experience after death, is something that Angel beats! is a pioneer of, and we’ll likely see other future shows use this idea to new ends.

While the show is indeed very strong and emotionally charged, there’s a good dose of comedy to keep things from going too dark. The comedy is handled rather expertly, and never really detracts from the main themes of the story, rather, it adds a great deal of entertainment to an already strong show. Its debatable whether Angel Beats! would be able to stand firm without its comedy element, as the shows funny moments are so expertly entwined and fixed into the core of the show’s appeal.

Of course, calling Angel beats! story perfect is something that is hard to do. If anything, a big feeling that is prevalent near the end of the series is that there just wasn’t enough time to properly make Jun Maeda’s epic into what it was intended to be. A lot of the characters’ stories are pushed aside in favor of the main characters and the series own quick resolution. Some of the series back-story is also left up for a prequel manga to address. At the end of it all, Angel beats! makes you feel like you’re only experiencing a chunk of a much grander, amazing story. If only anime series these days would be allowed 50 episodes or more like the good old days. Alas, Angel beats! only has 13 episodes to tell its tale, and while it can’t do justice to every plot point and finish every little detail, what it does, it does exceedingly well, and does so with flare, comedy and some good old tear jerker moments.

In a show that is both emotion driven and funny, it becomes essential that the characters in said show be superb. Indeed, Angel beats! has an amazing cast of characters. Each character has defining traits, is unique and above all, likeable. There isn’t a single character in this show that feels annoying, outdated or cliche’, which is an accomplishment in itself. There is the exceptional main character Yuzuru, the bossy and charismatic Yurippe, the funny and cool best bud Hinata, to the exceptionally weird T.K, Angel beats! has an impressive collection of characters. And while the story is indeed strong in this show, it is crafted in such a way that it focuses and highlights its characters expertly.

While the story and characters are amazing, the actual production and presentation of the show is where there are a few rough spots. The animation in particular, is downright ugly at times, especially in the starting episodes. That’s not to say that the animation is horrible throughout, as some scenes are clearly expertly animated. It just seems like the show either didn’t have enough of a budget or the budget management wasn’t smart enough. Whatever the case, there are some rather obvious parts of the show where the animation sticks out as a sore thumb.

The Art style, is the typical Visual Kei stuff that we’ve come to see in previous shows done by Kyoto Animation. It works well here, and while it’s nothing new or original, that’s hardly a problem. If its not broken, why fix it? It is worth noting though, that some of the character designs do feel borrowed from other more known anime(, particularly that of Yurippe).

The sound work is exceptional though, with an impressive score and amazing Opening and Endings songs. The voice acting is also superb, something that is often overlooked since most shows have great voice work these days, but it is worth commending the seiyuu (voice actors) on their performance, which add extra depth to the already impressive characters.

At the end of it all, Angel beats! is a show that is recommendable to any anime fan who’s liked funny, emotional stuff like Clannad,  AIR or Kanon. While it definitely feels like Maeda-san was not given the due budget and episode count that he deserved and needed, Angel beats! still manages to become one hell of a ride, with 13 amazingly entertaining episodes that finish on a high note. The show isn’t without its flaws, but what’s impressive is that none of these flaws matters in comparison to the shows amazing strengths.

We very much welcome Jun Maeda’s more direct involvement with the  anime industry, and give this show an A Grade.

~Reviewed By Setsuken

Post Info

Monthly Sponsor



Advertise on Anime Evo!

Help us pay the bills and work with us to promote your awesome product, service, website, comic or anything else you want to show off. We here at Anime Evo work with our advertising partners to promote products that are actually relevant to our audience, and give you the best bang for your buck!

Current Series

About

The Owner, webmaster, designer, coder and writer for the site. Anime Evo is Setsuken’s (Hassan's) proclamation of love for Anime, which he can’t seem to get enough of. He’s a 26 year old male, and current resides in the USA . A writer for a number of years Hassan is also a 3D Artist, a Game Designer, a Web Designer and a Huge Anime Obsessed Enthusiast.

Discussion Rules

Comments on Anime Evo are not only welcome, but the thing that we writers look forward to the most. Please, however, bear in mind that there are certain things that you just can't do as it ruins the fun for everyone:

  • No Spoilers of Any kind please. No hints, no discussion of future stuff from the source manga/light novel. Keep the discussion to the current episode's events, and that's it.
  • No personal attacks. Debates/Disagreements are okay, but keep things civil and be nice.
  • No advertising/Links to promote your personal website/article/products. We have a way to advertise on the site if you're interested.
  • Sumeiia

    lets not forget that Angel Beats! lives on in different formats! *downloading the Angel Beats drama cd* and there’s the manga. Or well two of them, one of which is supposed to pick up right where the anime ends 😀

  • Johan Liebert

    Bullshit. Angel Beats was worthless in every sense. Every part of it is a rehash of another show. The characters are generic and archetypal, they have no personality whatsoever, make generally stupid decisions, and are completely unlikeable. The plot doesn’t even know what it wants to be, flipping backwards and forwards over stupid ideas and concepts, and coming to a horribly rushed conclusion. As you said, “There’s a belief, that too many plot twists make a story convoluted.”, and contrary to what you said this show is the perfect example of this. And speaking of the conclusion, the last episode was horrible. Apparently, hack of a writer that he is, Jun Maeda seems to think that randomly being out of character in the last episode is tantamount to good character development. And then there’s that fucking twist at the end, where it turns out Angel has Otanashi’s heart. Obviously, he died second, since Angel was there before him, and yet his heart saved her life. FUCK THIS SHIT.

    Also, depth of character is NOT made by putting people through shitty backstories about how much their life sucked. These don’t add to any kind of three-dimensional character at all, largely because you could have tacked on the same arbitrary backstory to any other character regardless of personality. None of this actually shows through in how the characters are presented. None of them grow, develop, or do anything impressive. Most of them are simply there because they are archetypes that fans can relate to, and throwing random aspects on them to simulate depth makes fans think they are somehow good characters.

    Honestly, TK was the only good thing about this show.

    • I obviously disagree with what you have to say, though you do raise some interesting points and questions.

      First of all, I would disagree about the characters being stereotypical, or archetypal in the very pure sense. Yes, the characters were based off of the traditional anime archtypes, more so any Jun Maeda show, but he added a twist or interesting bit into each character to make them different from the pack.

      Example: Otonashi, he’s a lot like Clannad’s main character, but beyond the sarcasm, he’s unsure of himself and more than that, he’s a real do gooder who’d rather sacrifice himself for others than see someone else suffer. Tenshi is actually a lot like Nagato from Haruhi Suzumiya, but she actually HAS emotions and feelings but just can’t express them well.

      Those unique twists, and different variations on the standard tried and true characters are what make the cast of characters in Angel beats! so interesting.

      Moving on to the backstory, the backstories are a very clever device. Yes, the characters have totally different personalities from their previous lives versions, but the reaction and the change that results from each person remembering their past is definitely what makes the character development so rich and just really, puts a very interesting premise to light.

      What would you do if you forgot what you did in your previous, then remembered that it actually wasn’t a good life at all? And then you realized that you were being given a chance to get over whatever bad stuff that did happen to you? That’s the central idea behind Angel Beats!

      Its about regrets and letting go of them.

      I do strongly disagree with the whole point about characters growing. Each of them has their own problem or issue that they resolve by the end of the series. Yurippe accepts that she can actually be a good leader and caretaker, and that fighting destiny isn’t the only way for your life to mean something. Otonashi discovers that he really does want to help people, and that he actually doesn’t want to be alone.

      Kaede/Tenshi is able to express her feelings and what she was too awkward to be able to do.

      Yes, the romance between Otonashi and Kaede may seem a bit off, but it makes sense if Otonashi just blurted it out because he actually had someone who could understand him and who he could be with without the worry of losing them. I think, the spontaneity is kinda like how you’d suddenly ask a friend, a close friend out, just because you may think that you two would work best together. That said…

      Personally, I found Angel beats! to be a beautiful representation of human regret, how harsh life is, doing things for one another and just moving past stuff. It struck a chord with me, and for the above mentioned points. I do understand that some of these points may be hard to see, but there’s quite a bit of symbolism and clever play on human emotions that make Angel Beats! an impressive show.

      And I agree, TK was pretty sweet =D

  • Jay Agan

    Re. Mr Lieberts’ response: I don’t think they were being “randomly out of character” in the last ep. The battle is over, the menace is gone. Relief. Time to “let your hair down”, relax & move on. This last ep. actually made me want to watch the show again. It made more sense the second time around.

    As for lack of originality, there are only so many plots & character types out there. In this “mix n’ match” situation it isn’t originality that matters so much as how it is a shows’ creators handle the “cookie cutter” sameness. If it’s handled well, I’ll probably give it a look-see.

    More thought here:

    http://jaysteevee.blogspot.com/2010/10/not-haruhi-clone.html